Driveway Motion Detector Disappointment feature

7 Ways a Driveway Motion Detector Can Disappoint You

In Home Securityby Jody17 Comments

Say you want to increase your situational awareness at home and know when you have visitors (desired and unwanted). You could easily jump online and find a driveway motion detector to let you know when cars or people approach your house.  Or, you could hack your own driveway sensor to tie into your home automation system

Unfortunately:

False alarms may cause you to lose faith in the alerts and turn the thing off after a month of repositioning the unit and trying to make it work reliably

I’ll go over the technology used, make it easy to understand, and highlight ways the purchase you’re considering may disappoint you.

How Does a Driveway Motion Sensor Work?

First, let’s lay a foundation for you to understand how an outdoor motion sensor works before we move on.

There are three major categories of solutions in this space:

  • Thermal sensors
  • Magnetic sensors
  • Microwave or ultrasonic sensors

There are also beam sensors like you most often see in garages where transmitter and receiver modules form a “fence” across an opening.  But given the power demands and potential for false alerts, that implementation is usually not practical for outdoor applications.

The best sensors often pair two technologies in one unit, requiring a confirmation of an alert by the second, independent sensor. But naturally, that comes with cost and battery life compromises.

A Primer on Thermal Sensors

Thermal sensors (often called passive infrared or PIR sensors) are installed above ground and aimed across your driveway or away from your house to detect approaching vehicles or people. They are by far the most common type for wireless and battery powered applications since they only collect and don’t transmit any energy.

Infrared sensors use differences in the heat that they sense (infrared, non-visible light to be more precise) to determine when someone or something is approaching.

Advantage:

Thermal driveway sensors aren’t dependent on a particular type or composition of an object, but simply detect the presence of heat to alert you to a visitor.

Disadvantage:

Being above ground and dependent on heat, an infrared sensor is subject to sunlight and shadows, animals, windy days with lots of blowing objects, etc.

An Introduction to Magnetic Driveway Sensors

Magnetic sensors are, in many ways, the yin to a PIR sensor’s yang. They detect metal (ferrous metal like steel, iron and not aluminum) only, so there are not as many triggers for false alarms from the outset. They are often buried underground and protected from the elements and are easier to conceal.

Advantage:

Magnetic sensors are rock solid detecting cars when installed properly.

Disadvantage:

When’s the last time a magnet stuck to your hand?

My point is; a thief walking up your driveway in the middle of the night to steal the stuff out of your car won’t set a magnetic sensor off.

Active Sensors (Ultrasonic, Microwave, etc.)

I’m lumping these together since they all take the same approach.  Active sensors send out a pulse of energy and then process the returns to assess which objects are in view.  Then, they save that return and compare it to subsequent returns to determine when there are changes.

If you know how radar or sonar work, it’s a really primitive version of those approaches.

Advantage:

Actively transmitting energy can be a good way to overcome a noisy environment that would cause false alarms to a passive sensor.

Disadvantage:

It takes energy to transmit those pulses of energy, so active sensors are generally not a battery-friendly application.

So which is best for you? Read on and learn about how each can fail you in critical situations to help you decide when type of sensor makes the most sense for you.

Driveway motion sensor fails!

driveway motion detector fails - facepalm

1. It might not go off when a car goes by

Type: Thermal

Explanation: What happens on a hot summer day when a warm car is the same temperature as the air around it? What if a cold car in your driveway cranks up and leaves and your sensor doesn’t pick up the warm exhaust as it passes by? Many people report problems with their driveway sensors not reliably detecting the primary thing they wanted to know about, cars!

2. You get false alarms on windy days

Type: Thermal

Explanation: Any movement by a warm (relative to its surroundings) object can set a thermal driveway sensor off. Yes, that includes the bush on the other side of the driveway with the sun on it.

3. It alerts you every time a car drives by on the road or when your neighbor gets home

Type: Magnetic

Explanation: You’ve placed your sensor too close to other triggers.

When you’re dealing with thousands of pounds of iron and steel, sensors can be designed to detect moving cars at impressive ranges. The sensitivity of your magnetic sensor will depend on the design of the electronics, ranges to objects, size and material of the objects, and how fast they pass by. And, if you don’t read the installation instructions carefully (or get a lousy set of instructions), you may put the sensor too close to other objects that will set it off.

4. Rain and snow storms cause it fits

Type: Thermal

Explanation: Just like a warm object blowing in front of the sensor could set it off, a passing sheet of rain or blowing snow can also cause rapid temperature changes that might set your driveway sensor off.

5. Your driveway motion detector is a GREAT animal detector

Type: Thermal

Explanation: A cat that is 3 feet from the sensor looks just as large to the sensor as a car 20 feet away. You might get alerts for every dog in the neighborhood that stops to take a leak, every deer munching on your flowers, and STILL miss the delivery van.

6. It can’t take the cold

Type: Both

Explanation: Batteries dislike cold weather. Alkaline batteries REALLY dislike cold weather. Expect service life to cut in half below about -10 C for standard alkaline and NiMH batteries. They may even freeze and burst (NOT good). Try Lithium batteries for longer life and better performance in temperature extremes.

7. It doesn’t tell you when people approach your house on foot

Type: Magnetic

Explanation: Want to know about that sketchy guy claiming to sell security before he gets to your door? Interested in someone snooping around your cars at 2 AM? A magnetic sensor just isn’t going to get the job done. So, you either need a thermal sensor as an auxiliary sensor or a dog who’s a night owl.

Your choice!

How to Reduce False Alarms and Increase Reliability of Your Driveway Motion Sensor

If you’ve already made a purchase or know you’ll have to live with compromises, you’re still not at the end of your rope.  Here are a few things to try for thermal and ultrasonic sensors:

  • Try to mount your sensor a few feet off of the ground to pick up the hot exhaust from cars
  • Create a sun shade over the sensor or hang it under an eave to protect it from direct sunlight interfering with its thermal sensor.
  • Place the sensor high enough to point over the backs of animals you expect to frequent the area and avoid pointing the sensor directly at the ground.
    evil cat

    I’ll teach you to leave me outside at night

  • Locate the sensor where it isn’t pointing at large, easily movable objects like tree branches and shrubs.
  • Protect thermal sensors from the weather. The farther away blowing snow and rain are from the sensor, the less likely you will have problems. Obviously, this depends on where you live too.
  • If you’re still having problems, you can try to use tape or paint to limit the field of view of the sensor.
    Motion detector field of view modification

    Paint or cover the red areas with tape to limit the field of view and block problem areas

For the magnetic sensors, there are a few options as well:

  • Test the location of your magnetic sensor BEFORE burying it and the wire going to your wireless transmitter to make sure cars on the road and in the neighbor’s driveway don’t set it off.
  • Consider using a magnetic sensor to detect cars and supplementing with a thermal sensor at night when sun and shade won’t give it fits. Of course, you need a more sophisticated home automation or security system to implement that unless you want to turn speakers on and off twice every day.

Hopefully, that gets you on your way to beefing up your home’s security.  Make sure you check out my article of other affordable DIY home security tips before you go.

And if you want to beef up your driveway security even more, check out the guide to connecting a gate to your home automation system.

If you have any questions, I’m an engineer so too nerdy is not even possible. Ask away!

Comments

  1. Beam alarms are cheap (50 dollars) and don’t false on windy days or sunlight, they are low voltage(12v). I’ve had them installed for 11 years, only one false and that was caused by deer. They really are the best way to go.

    1. Thanks for the info, John. Can you share which model you’re using? I’ll link it up in the article for those that don’t read down this far.

  2. We have a Dakota magnetic driveway alarm system. Sometimes it works well…sometimes it doesn’t. There is some sort of issue when humidity levels in the air change such as a light rain for example, which makes the system go off continuously. We are not near a public road. The nearest source of metal is about 50 feet away. Getting frustrated. Any ideas?

    1. Author

      That’s quite a predicament! The engineers at Dakota would give you much better guesses than this engineer, but I’m willing to try. 🙂 Unfortunately, I’m not sure I have enough information for a working theory yet. Can you answer a few questions?
      1) Has it behaved like this since day 1? If not, when did it go awry?
      2) Are there any conditions other than light rain that also cause higher false alarm rates? Storms? Fog? Lightning?

  3. Do you know of a sensor that can determine when a car enters the driveway but does not go off when it leaves the driveway?

    1. Author

      Something like the FMCW radars they initially used on cars comes to mind, but I’ve never heard of a commercial one for a driveway, sorry.

  4. I share a driveway with my neighbor. We aren’t friendly. He rents as do I but he put CCTV cameras up everywhere 3 pointing my way. Then he added no trespassing signs/you will be prosecuted. Now it’s a driveway alarm. I can’t hear it of course but I’m annoyed that he’s monitoring my comings and goings. Though he has many vehicles ( he states he sells cars been here a year all still here), no one visits him. Thus, what cars could he be counting but mine and my visitors? The trouble is based on the fact that he goes out back and forth 2pm-2am daily. He’s selling math and cocaine and I’m a retired police officer from out of state. I believe he now knows I know so he’s trying to annoy me into moving. How can I interfere with the signal without harming or touching it? Can it be done? What if I get one of my own and aim it directly at his beam? Sounds silly but I’m getting bugged!

    1. Author

      The laser based devices alert when the beam is broken. So, you would have to do something to obscure the beam 100% of the time (in which case it may just constantly alarm and be replaced) or replace the intended source with an alternate light source on the same side of the road as the receiver so that a car would not block your countermeasure.

      Alternatively, you could exploit the wireless path back to the receiver in his house with a jammer. But, operating a high power jammer can get you in trouble with the FCC at a minimum. 🙂

  5. My Bunker Hill Security driveway sensor light stays on 24/7. What is wrong? It only began this a couple of days ago. The unit is about a month old.

    1. Author

      I’m not familiar with that unit, but unless you’re missing a setting or something it sounds like a premature failure to me.

  6. We have a shared gravel driveway and one neighbor (I think) has taken to almost stopping at the end of our driveway at dusk for some tens of seconds, and seems to be looking over our property. I want to turn on a security light to discourage this. What sort of sensor would you suggest?

  7. Could you rig up a system with two sensors? If the furthest one is triggered before the nearest one then the object is moving towards the house and the alarm sounds. If the nearest sensor is triggered first then the object is moving away and the alarm does not sound.

    If only one sensor is triggered within a small time period then it is likely to be an animal crossing the road.

    1. Author

      I guess you could use two different chimes, but it would be really nice to have both synchronized. You’d likely have to write some custom software in HomeAssistant or a SmartThings app to make that happen.

  8. Hey Jody!
    Enjoyed your article on motion sensors. I’m looking to use a cheap PIR motion detector to notify me when the newspaper is left in the area below the mailbox. It’s open to the street so I’m afraid it’ll pick up passing cars. Could I use tape over the outside edges of the fresnel lens to limit the range? Any other ideas will be appreciated as well.
    Thanks!

    1. Author

      Hey Ron, I would try to mount it on the top (if you have enough room) facing down and tape off the side of the lens that is exposed to the road. It sounds like you’ve got a good plan! Hopefully, you can get reliable signal out at the mailbox.

  9. All I want is a sensor that will turn on the lights when we pull under the the carport.

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.