You could spend hours reading reviews to find the best DIY security systems.
But who wants to do that?
Better one person (that’s me) spend their time finding and reading them for the benefit of many people and summarizing things for the rest, right?
Here’s What I Did:
We already have a huge page summarizing the best reviews of home security systems that we could find in detail. But, it’s a lot to get through.
I thought a quick summary might be more helpful to folks and set out to create this page. I’ve included camera systems with security features as well as home automation features, because the alerts and notification capabilities are practically the same as do it yourself alarm systems.
They all help you keep an eye on things at home.
- First, find the quality reviews on the web. Toss the ones without clear evidence of being a hands-on review. Throw out all of the ones that didn’t discuss the product in detail.
- Throw them all in a spreadsheet with a scaled, common scoring system.
- Calculate an average rating for each security system.
- Rank the systems based on their mean score.
If you think I missed a good review that wasn’t considered, drop it in the comments below.
Now, I’ll be the first to tell you that rankings can’t be all things to all people. In fact, I don’t care for them myself because they’re rarely objective. Sadly, many places use them to make more money in commissions.
But, I do recognize the value in a “Top X” list for helping you quickly eliminate bad products.
So, hopefully, you take the information on this page to find a few good systems, compare their costs and features, and then read a few reviews to settle in on your decision.
That’s a process I can get behind!
What You Won’t See
I’ve already said you’ll see a camera system and home automation systems. You’ll even see some options that offer professional monitoring services as an option.
But, I’m drawing a hard line at alarm systems without a practical self-monitored option (including Simplisafe tests that rule) or that require piecing together disparate control panels and sensors from various Honeywell or Elk security system parts.
I appreciate the DIY mentality as much as anybody, but also understand we are a special breed. So, I haven’t included the really hodge-podge solutions, maybe some other time.
Top DIY Home Security Systems
In the table below, like we do many other places on the site, we sometimes provide links that go to security products on Amazon as well as a link directly to the manufacturer’s website. If you use the first link, you’ll be supporting our work here at no cost to you. If not, just use the other link.
The review links will either take you to reviews that we’ve done or a list of the reviews used to calculate these scores.
|SimpliSafe - site||#1||4.5||SimpliSafe Review|
|SmartThings - site||#2||4.3||SmartThings Reviews|
|Piper - site||#3||4.1||Piper Reviews|
|iSmartAlarm - site||#4||4.0||iSmartAlarm Review|
|Staples Connect (new D-Link hub)||#5||3.8||Staples Connect Reviews|
|Scout Alarm - site||#6||3.8||Scout Review|
|Insteon - site||#7||3.5||Insteon Reviews|
|Skylink Home - site||#7||3.5||Skylink Reviews|
|Oplink Connected - site||#7||3.5||Oplink Reviews|
|Quirky Wink Hub - site||#10||3.4||Wink Reviews|
|Iris Smart Kit - site||#11||3.3||Iris Reviews|
|Viper Starter Kit - site||#12||3.3||Viper Reviews|
|Nexia Home - site||#13||3.2||Nexia Reviews|
What Did We Learn
Well, for one, there’s a lot of variety at the top of the list! Take the top 4 for instance:
- Simplisafe really pushes monitored services, limiting features and apps for anything but the most expensive tier. But, they offer a solid system that’s been around a while.
- SmartThings is well-reviewed home automation system that recently announced a revamped security module for their app.
- Piper is a camera that also has some automation capabilities.
- iSmartAlarm is the only truly pure-play DIY security system on this list.
Depending on what you’re needs are, one of those would likely address you needs really well. To know for sure, make sure you check out their features and compare costs on our security system comparison page. You can also see which sensors and protocols each system supports here.
Hope that Helps!
We started this site to help people, so hopefully we’ve checked that off for you today. If you appreciate the leg work, considering sharing this online or following us on Facebook.